Making Chocolate at Home

Happy Montoso Gardens Customer

So, you just got your fresh cacao fruits and want to make chocolate, what now?

A simple chocolate can be made at home using common and inexpensive tools and materials. Chocolate has been made from cacao seeds on a small scale since around 1900 BC, by the ancient Olmecs, Aztecs and Mayans in what is now southern Mexico and Central America.

Mayan Cacao Goddess
Mayan cacao goddess holding a cacao pod. From around 250-650 AD. From Escuintla, Guatemala. In the Choco-Story Paris Museum.

The original form that chocolate was consumed was as a hot drink, mixing the roasted and ground cacao seeds with vanilla, chili and other spices. Solid chocolate was developed much later, in the 1800s, after cacao was introduced into Europe. The basic steps in making chocolate are fermentation of the fresh seeds, sun drying of the fermented seeds, roasting, dehulling and winnowing, and grinding.

Bodegón de mujer echando chocolate en una mancerina
“Bodegón de Mujer Echando Chocolate en una Mancerina”. Painting by Félix Lorente (1712-1787) showing hot chocolate being poured into a cup by a chocolate vendor.

Fermentation
The fresh seeds with the adhering pulp are extracted from the recently harvested fruits and placed into a pile or container, where naturally occurring yeasts and bacteria use the sugars in the pulp, producing heat, alcohol and finally acetic acid.

Opening Cacao Pods
Removing fresh cacao seeds from harvested pods for a “mini-fermentation” in styrofoam coolers.

This process kills the seed embryo and causes chemical changes in the seed which contribute to the development of chocolate flavor. On a home scale, the seeds can be fermented in a small Styrofoam cooler.

Fermenting Cacao Seeds Covered With Banana Leaves
The fermenting seeds are covered with banana or heliconia leaves to keep in heat and moisture. You could use any large non toxic leaf or something like waxed paper.

A small amount of seeds may not produce sufficient heat, and the cooler may be placed inside a closed vehicle in the sun to help the fermentation process.

Checking Temperature in Fermenting Cacao
During fermentation the seeds can reach 120F or a little higher. In a small batch, you might have to put them into a hot car or oven on low heat to achieve those temperatures.

White seeded Criollo are completely fermented in 2-3 days, while purple seeded Trinitario and Forastero types take approximately 7-8 days to ferment completely. Properly fermented seeds turn from white or purple to a uniform brown color, and are now referred to as “beans”.

Fresh and Fermented Cacao Beans
Fresh cacao seeds on the left and fermented beans on the right.

Sun drying
The fermented beans may be dried either washed or unwashed, but beans with the residue of fermented pulp washed off will dry faster. The beans can be dried in the sun, on a hard surface such as a concrete patio, on a screen under cover or inside a hot car, or in an oven on low heat. The beans are fully dry when they are brittle and snap open easily. At this stage the beans can be shelled and eaten as raw nibs.

Solar Dryer for Cacao Beans
Fermented cacao beans drying in a solar dryer. They can also be dried on a screen inside a hot car or in an oven on low heat.

Roasting
The heat of roasting changes and develops the chocolate flavor, and helps to facilitate the separation of the seed hull from the roasted bean. The beans are roasted at 350-400F for 15-30 minutes, and can be roasted lighter or darker to taste. They can be roasted in an open cast iron pan, stirring continually, or in an oven. When properly roasted, the beans turn dark brown, some may pop slightly, and have a chocolatey brownie-like (but not burnt) smell.

Winnowing Cacao Nibs
The nibs are separated from broken seed shells by pouring them through a stream of air, here with an electric fan. The lighter shells blow out of the dish while the heavier nibs fall inside. You may have to do it a few times to get them clean.

Dehulling and winnowing
The roasted bean and seed coat are very brittle and break apart easily. Dehulling is the process of breaking the bean and seed coat into pieces and then separating the two. The beans can be broken into nibs with a wooden mortar and pestle, or by gently crushing them with a rolling pin or heavy wine bottle. They can be first placed inside a large ziplock bag to keep the pieces from flying around the kitchen. Once all the beans are broken, the hulls can be separated from the nibs by winnowing in the wind or in front of a fan. A hair dryer can also be used to blow the lighter hulls out of a wide bowl, while leaving behind the heavier nibs.

Clean Cacao Nibs
Cleaned nibs ready to be ground into chocolate.

Grinding
The cleaned nibs can be eaten alone or used in baking, but to make either a chocolate drink or solid chocolate, they need to be ground as finely as possible. Traditionally, cacao beans were ground on a heated stone metate, and this is still one way to make chocolate at home. Other methods include grinding the nibs in a heated stone mortar or in a Corona grain mill. Heating the nibs and the grinding equipment melts the cocoa butter and helps to liquefy the ground nibs. Probably the best way to grind the nibs is with a Champion Juicer. Ground nibs of 100% cacao is called “cacao liquor”, although it doesn’t have any alcohol. Homemade chocolate will always have a somewhat gritty texture, as it is practically impossible to reduce the particles to a size less than 14 microns, as do the commercial stone melangers, but the resulting chocolate is still delicious.

Cacao Liquor
Cacao “liquor”, or 100% ground cacao. This is 100% chocolate with no sugar, dried milk or any other ingredients. It is somewhat bitter and gritty but tastes and smells very chocolatey.

When grinding, other ingredients can be added, including 20-30% sugar (or more, to taste), vanilla beans, cinnamon, nutmeg or other spices, dried hot peppers, dried milk, or dried fruits. Pure ground nibs make a dark bitter chocolate with a 100% cacao content, and adding other ingredients will decrease the final cacao percentage. A good dark chocolate can have 50% or 80% (or more) cacao content, while cheap milk chocolate can have as little as 15% cacao (the rest is fillers).

Premier Chocolate Refiner-Melanger
Sugar being added to cacao liquor to make a 70% dark chocolate. This refining or conching step with a melanger is optional but improves the flavor and makes the chocolate smooth.

The finished semi liquid chocolate can made molded into balls, sticks, bars or other shapes, and will solidify as it cools… enjoy!!!

Home Made Chocolate
Home made chocolate used to dip dried bananas and poured into square and round shapes.